The Best Parts of Us (Before the Worst Took Over): A Beyond the Gates commentary by Soap Central founder Dan J Kroll for the week ending November 13, 2026.
Hundreds if not thousands of songs have been written about love that has faded away or good times that are now just a memory. What’s interesting is that not everyone looks back at the past in the same way. For some, a single less-than-pleasurable moment can spoil the entirety of an otherwise happy memory. A partner’s affair can make some believe that whole relationship was a lie.
Hayley tried her best to con Bill into believing that there had been something real in their fake marriage. She urged him to think of her unborn baby as a vessel for the best parts of both of them. Nicole shared that she now believed that her marriage to Ted was never really all that great because of his affair. Louis Hamilton had a vision of what he wanted his life to be. Then a baby came into the picture, and nothing was ever the same again.
Is it really possible to separate the malignancies from otherwise happy memories or is that just the kind of thing you read about in self-help blogs?
Donโt have time to read the entire Beyond the Gates column? You can now stream an audio/podcast version of this commentary โ complete with off-script silliness, bloopers, interviews, and more. And itโs totally free to download or stream. SPOTIFY | APPLE MUSIC | AMAZON MUSIC | iHEART RADIO
Having A Family Can Bring Out Who You Are
The Monday, November 9, episode of Beyond the Gates was a really nice example of what the show does so well. It was a duck floating on a pond. On the surface, it might seem like not much happened. Only three sets were used and only seven characters โ Anita, Bill, Caroline, Chelsea, Dani, Naomi, and Vernon — were featured. Nine if you count flashbacks of Billโs mom and dad. But underneath, the duckโs legs were moving wildly back and forth to keep the duck going where it wanted to go. In this case, under the surface we learned more about Bill than we have in the past 21 months.
Weโve heard about Billโs father in passing on multiple occasions. We knew that both Bill and Vernon had a very negative opinion of the man, but little else. Now, we know why. Louis Hamilton never wanted a child โ and he made sure to let Bill know that every chance he had.
Everything Bill did was an annoyance and inconvenience to his father โ even something that should seemingly be celebratory. Louis was furious when Bill chose to go to a local college. He was hoping Bill would go to a school in California and stay thereโฆ never to be seen or heard from again.
As Bill thought about his life and the paternity test results that proved he was the father of Hayleyโs unborn child, Bill was taken aback by what he perceived was an unexpected similarity between himself and his father. Bill wanted nothing to do with the child that Hayley was carrying. Billโs greatest fear had come true. He had become his father.
Or had he?
The Cat’s In the Cradle
Caroline did her best to remind Bill that even if he was โnot husband of the year material,โ he had always been a great father to Chelsea and Naomi. Caroline might have been a circus performer in a past life. She did a great job of tightrope walking between being the friend Bill wanted and the friend he needed. There are few people that I think could be totally honest with Bill in that moment.
There was also a little nugget dropped that spoke to some of theories or ideas that people have had. We learned that when Bill and Dani were married, people (though it wasnโt clarified who these people were) had suspected that Caroline was one of the many women that Bill had bedded. They both made it clear that they had never been together. And, through intonation and body language, made it fairly clear that any sort of impropriety had never crossed their minds.
I donโt know that Bill was what one would call a โmommaโs boy,โ but he definitely had a very close relationship with his mother. Before leaving for college, Bill vowed to one day make his mother proud of him. She, like many mothers before and after her, told her son that he already had.
You Know I’m Gonna Be Like You
Bill seemed to know at an early age that his mom and dad were only together because they were having a child together. Billโs mom desperately hoped that a baby would fix their broken union. Sadly, that wasnโt the case. Bill seemed to harbor feelings of guilt that his existence in the world had caused his mother to stop being who she wanted to be. She altered her very essence and gave up any dream of what her life could have been to raise a son with a man who didnโt want a child โ and, quite possibly, her.
That then got me thinking. I am not a psychologist, and I donโt play one on TV. But I did audit some online courses at Nicole Dupree University. In Billโs adult life, Dani was his mother. After meeting Bill, Dani gave up her life as a model to be a wife and mother. Though Dani has been very vocal that she didnโt regret giving up her career, she has, on at least one occasion, wondered what might have been had life gone differently.
Unlike his dad, Bill loved both of his daughters from day one. Heโs been supportive. With all that said, it does make me wonder why Chelsea had been so fearful to come out to Bill, but not to Dani. Did something happen along the way to make Chelsea think heโd take the news differently?
But back to Bill. I wonder if Bill subconsciously believed or felt that he had โforcedโ Dani to quit her career as a model. That sort of self-loathing might have been a contributing factor to his self-destructive behavior of sexing anything with a pulse.
With Billโs relationship with his father now clearer, itโs easy to understand why Bill became so attached to Vernon. Vernon was everything that Louis was not. It explains why Bill has apologized to Vernon on numerous occasions for the way he treated Dani. There was always something โoffโ about Billโs apologies and now it makes sense. Bill was probably more upset that heโd disappointed Vernon than he was that heโd hurt Dani and his daughters. Heโd finally found the dad heโd always wanted and then lost him through his own actions.
When You Comin’ Home, Dad?
Iโve always believed that Billโs dad would one day resurface. The recent flashbacks make me think itโs more inevitable than ever. Iโm not sure what will bring about Billโs dad’s return, but I have a few ideas that Iโve crafted in my soapy little brain. The two most obvious scenarios are Bill deciding that he needs to see his dad for closure and Billโs dad showing up in the DMV to make peace with Bill before he dies.
Taking things a bit further, it seems unlikely that Louis would come to town needing some sort of organ or tissue donation to stay alive. We had a twist on that with Eva getting a portion of half-sister and nemesis Kat’s liver. That said, Bill and Kat have always had an unusually close relationship. That might provide them the opportunity to strengthen their bond and become sounding boards for one another.
But It’s Sure Nice Talking To You, Dad
Thereโs another twist that I thought of. To be fair, I actually thought this was going to happen on this weekโs Greyโs Anatomy, but since it didnโt, I get to use my theory here. Maybe Louis shows up in the DMV under the guise of wanting to atone for his past wrongs. Letโs say that Bill is open to the idea of trying to work through their difficult past. Just when things are looking okay, Louis drops his โIโm dyingโ or โI need a donationโ bombshell.
Bill would then be torn about what he should do. Then, when Bill agrees, he learns that his dad isnโt dying โ and he really didnโt want to have a relationship with Bill. Instead, we learn that Louis started another family somewhere and one of his other children is the one that needs the life-saving donation. Louis was only nice to Bill because he was worried about a son or daughter that he actually loved.
I have no idea if Beyond the Gates would do another organ donation storyline so soon, but I think it would give Timon Kyle Durrett even more meaty material to sink his teeth into.
Tell Me Sweet Little Lies
You know the trouble with a con person? You never know when they are actually telling the truth. Weโve gotten a better understanding of Billโs upbringing, but do we have any idea if anything Hayley said about her past is true?
Dani has made several digs about Hayley being an โorphan,โ but is she? Hayley and Randy havenโt really had much discussion about their respective families and life in Philadelphia. We know they are cousinsโฆ but thatโs about it. We donโt know anything about the branches of the actual family tree. Well, maybe thatโs not entirely true. We know that Randy has a kid that weโve never seen.
I fake-o-analyzed Bill, so let me keep things going with Hayley. I know that a baby doesnโt fit into her whole conning lifestyle, but I wonder if any part of her well-expressed loathing of kids has to do with not having her parents around when she was young. Youโd think that maybe the pendulum would swing in the other direction and Hayley would want to be a super-parent to a child. That might not be the way things work in Hayleyโs brain.
If I Could Turn the Page
I thought there might be a small chance โ however miniscule โ that Leslieโs parenting peptalk might make Hayley change her mind about the baby. That didnโt happen. Instead, Hayley plucked through Leslieโs story like she was digging for deals in the sale bin at Neiman Marcus. When she came up for air, she didnโt have a Gucci this or a Dolce that. No, she had pearls โ pearls of wisdom.
Hayley marched her behind over to Billโs office where she used portions of Leslieโs story to try to make Bill reconsider his decision to sever his parental rights. I donโt know if it was supposed to be funny, but I was tickled. She called her baby, โthe best parts of us before the worst took over.โ She reminded Bill that their baby was an โinnocent soul that represents hope.โ What hope? Hope that Bill might forgive Hayley and do right by the child.
But there was more.
Hayley turned on the waterworks and claimed that a part of her truly did care about Bill. Why else, she asked, would she have honored their wedding vows? Bill reached down for the ultrasound photo and looked at it. For a moment I thought sheโd had him. Thankfully, Bill saw through the performance, summoned Tomas, and ordered Hayley out of the building.
Itโs not just babies and moms that Hayley doesnโt seem to like. She probably hates bunnies, cotton candy, world peaceโฆ and too many other things to mention. Hayley also seems to hate the very idea of parenting. Weโve already seen her disdain of Bill being a dad to Chelsea and Naomi. Now she hates Anita Dupreeโs success story and her unflinching determination to protect her children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren.
Oh, No, No, You Can’t Disguise
Hayley fired off a barrage in Anitaโs direction that no anti-missile system was going to be able to protect her from. First, she mused that the last time Anita was pregnant was, โa hundred years ago.โ When Anita asked Hayley if there were โno depths to which [Hayley] would not sink,โ Hayley noted that โthe Queen of Fairmont Crest is the Queen of Hypocrisy.โ
I was on the edge of my seat โ well, the sofa โ wondering if Hayley was going to get so angry that sheโd say something about โthat nightโ that she shouldnโt. Iโll give Hayley credit: she does seem to appreciate the threat of being chopped up into even more bite-sized pieces.
When Anita warned that Hayley was on the verge of a metaphorical beat down, Hayley put a little bass in her voice and asked, โOooh, is that a little Cabrini Green coming out to play?โ Hayley also tossed in a jab about Barbara.
Poor Laura has been off-screen for weeks. She finally ventures out of the house to have a little meeting with Anita at Uptown and catches strays.
To Make It to the Border of Mexico
If you’ve read my columns for any length of time, you’ll know that I find humor in the most unusual places. There are things that tickle my funny bone and I don’t even know if they are supposed to be funny. There was a perfect example of this on Beyond the Gates this week. First, let me set the scene.
I thought it was so smart for Martin to ask Smitty to put his call with Max on speakerphone so that Martin could record it. I wasn’t sure that it would be able to be submitted into evidence due to privacy and recording laws, but I figured we’d cross that bridge at a later date. Instead, Naomi explained that it was a terrible idea for Smitty to be communicating on a burner phone with the man that the police believed had supplied the drugs that killed Lia Whitmore.
Still, Naomi decided that she needed to listen to the content of the recording. Then, in what can only be called the most random of coincidences, Naomi recognized the church bells ringing in the background of the recording because she’d heard them once when she was doing some research on places to visit in Mexico. Seriously? It was like a church bell equivalent to being able to Name That Tune in one note. Or how Sherlock Holmes can see a single insect wing at a crime scene and know that it’s a rare fruit fly from a remote region of South America that only three people have ever seen before. It was so absolutely obscure and ridiculous that it made me laugh long enough that I needed to rewind to hear what I missed over my laughter.
Lived Nine Lives, Gunned Down Ten
So what does one do when they think they know the exact location of random church bells heard on an illicit recording? They hop on Expedia and book a flight to Mexico! Duh.
In Mexico, Naomi and Martin looked all over town until they found an apartment they believed to be occupied by Max’s cousin. A woman answered the door and told them to go away. But Martin and Naomi weren’t going anywhere. They lingered in the hallway long enough to hear a man’s voice coming from inside. Still, they lingered. After what seemed like an eternity, Max opened the door and told Martin and Naomi to hurry up and get inside.
Max explained that he’d left the Witness Protection Program and went into hiding in his cousin’s apartment because the Impaler’s goons were looking for him. Max confirmed that the video of him and Smitty together was fake, but he flat-out refused to return to the U.S. and testify to it. Martin said he could offer Max protection or anything that he might need. Max was quick to reject the offer. If Martin wasn’t able to protect his own husband, how was he going to protect a virtual stranger?
The entire time they were talking my eyes were fixed on the window in the back of the room. I was absolutely convinced that someone was going to shoot Max through the widow. I was so convinced that I even made the “pyew pyew” gunshot noises during a break in the conversation.
Beside, Behind, Betwix and Beyond The Gates
Welcome to the Speed Round, inspired by the way Nicole Dupree blows through that stop sign every day in the Beyond the Gates opening credits. Here are some of the thoughts and observations about other things that happened this week on Beyond the Gates.
Music Box
Might we finally be getting some Beyond the Gates music in our Spotify playlists? Anita mentioned that the publicists and other music insiders loved the re-recorded Articulettes song โ which we now know is titled โShine Together.โ That makes me wonder if the folks at CBS, Procter & Gamble, and the NAACP had decided that the fictional girl group should get a real-world release.
Even if it doesnโt, I was able to rip โCome Closer,โ Anitaโs jazz song, and โShine Togetherโ to MP3 files. So if you ever visit Kroll Manor, you might just hear Anita, Barbara, Sharon, and Tracy singing in the background. There might even be a whole dance routine with a spatula and a cookie sheet. But since I am not on TikTok, I guess weโll never know.
All the Small Things
For years, soap fans, myself included, have demanded that soaps remember that small details matter. In 2026, it seems like the script has flipped and viewers donโt sweat the small stuff and, maybe worse, think trivial information is boring.
Whatโs brought this up? I thought it was really, really smart to mention that ChelseaKat is having trouble with knockoff handbags being sold on Canal Street in New York. It probably wonโt be a big story point, but I like that it was mentioned. Itโs something that a real, successful fashion company would have to deal with. Itโs just another reminder that Beyond the Gates exists somewhere closer to reality than fiction.
You’ve Given Me A Heart Attach
I thought the whole Noah/Heart Attach thing was really funny. I was marveled by Noah saying that he was approached by a recruiter. The escort site has recruiters? Boy, does that give new meaning to “LinkedIn.” After learning of Noah’s new side hustle, Nicole quietly slipped out of her office to deal with a “patient.” It turns out she made that up so that she could call Vanessa and warn her. Vanessa’s reaction was perfection.
What was interesting to me was hearing Deanna defend Noah’s decision to be an escort. She explained that her generation doesn’t shame those working in the sex industry because sex workers have been around since the dawn of time.
It all turned out to be a big, horribly executed joke. Noah didn’t agree to work for Heart Attach. He was approached by a recruiter and he initially wanted to play a joke on his dad — but Kial wasn’t around so he decided Nicole and Kat were the next best thing.
End Of the Road
Are we nearing the end of the Impaler’s reign of terror? Heather went off on Vanessa, calling her a “stupid bitch” for what seemed like no reason. Hoping to sow some discontent between Vanessa and Joey, Heather even snarled, “You do know that he lies to you, like, all the time, right?” I was enjoying Vanessa and Heather’s tรชte-ร -tรชte and wanted it to go on for another scene or two, but Vanessa had enough and stormed out of Uptown.
When Vanessa tracked down Joey, she told him of her encounter with Heather. That’s all Joey needed to hear. For weeks we’ve heard him warn that he could end Heather. It seems like we might finally be getting to that point.
BTG: Behind the Graphic
I haven’t made the graphic yet.
Beyond the Gates: Lines of the Week
The Beyond the Gates writing team seems to be having a little too much fun. Here are some of the lines of dialogue that tickled my funny bone or that I found memorable over the past week (and haven’t already mentioned in this column).
โYou may not be husband of the year materialโฆโ
Caroline with a Captain Obvious assessment of Bill Hamilton’s life.
โHave the place fumigated as well.โ
Bill to Caroline when she said sheโd call a cleaning service to clean up the room heโd trashed.
โHis circus no longer belongs in my tent.โ
Dani, referring to how her life needed to go on without Bill being a part it.
โYou make it sound like a cult with diapers.โ
Hayley after Leslie talked up the joys of motherhood.
โWell then listen up, heffa, because youโre gonna hear it again.โ
Leslie hoping to stave off Hayley’s sassing as she told a story that Hayley might have heard before.
โ’Nice’ is a vanilla-scented candle.โ
Eye-rolling Leslie when Hayley said Leslie’s time at the Articulettes’s recording session “sounds nice.”
โWould you please escort Miss whatever sheโs going by out of the building?โ
Bill when he asked Tomas to escort Hayley out of the building
Gatecrashers: Reader and Viewer Feedback
I love interacting with other Beyond the Gates fans. So I thought Iโd create a section to share some of the comments Iโve received on my columns and social media posts. If youโd like to see your comments shared here, you can scroll down to the Comments section below this column and post away. You can also chat with me on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads, Facebook, and/or TwitterX.
Follow my Random Acts of Dan
That’s all I have for this week’s My View From Beyond the Gates column. Thank you for reading and, as always, please feel free to share your thoughts on my column or Beyond the Gates in the Comments section below.
If you’ve enjoyed my column this week and want to see what I have written about Beyond the Gates in previous weeks, you can check those out in the My View From Beyond the Gates archive.
Have a penchant for gardening, interior design, or fixing up old houses? Check out my Manor Makeover series where I write about all of the things I’ve been up to here at Kroll Manor in Allentown, PA, over the past decade.
To keep up with all of the shenanigans I engage in on social media, please consider giving my a follow on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads, Facebook, and TwitterX.
Life outside the gates
Two of my former Two Scoops columnists from Soap Central, Liz Masters and Tamilu, have joined me here on my personal web site — and they are still writing about General Hospital. Liz is on deck with week with a new column called, Dial K For Killow.
To read more thoughts, opinions, rants, and raves about daytime television, be sure to check out our Editorial section.
dan





I laughed with you when Haley was using Leslie’s lines on Bill. Another great week for BTG – loving the show even more this past month!
I’m pretty sure at one point I remember Haley talking with Randy about how her mother, or at least the woman who raised her, wasn’t a good person and had no interest or business being a mother.
I had a feeling those bells in the phone recording with Max would be a clue. However, I figured it would involve them trying to narrow down churches with that bell in order to track down Max’s cousin’s place. I’m pretty sure Mexico has a lot of churches and a lot of them probably use bells. For Naomi to have known which specific church based off one visit to Mexico is a bit out there, but okay.